Can anyone explain the editorial policy?

Image credit: Pixabay

A few posts ago, Anne Linehan credited Chronicle Outlook editor David Langworthy for a “frank column” acknowledging public concerns about shortcomings of the mainstream media.

Recognizing the problem surely is a start, but my most recent experience of being ignored by the Chronicle‘s reader representative James T. Campbell and Langworthy himself suggests that the newspaper still has a ways to go in being responsive to readers who have questions about editorial policy and decisions.

To back up a bit — I actually wondered about the Chronicle‘s official policy on bylines for op-eds when I ran across a complaint on Charles Kuffner’s blog that the newspaper had run an op-ed with a “ridiculously uninformative byline….” Apparently, Kuffner thinks that the newspaper needs to edit supplied bylines. I got to thinking about it, and realized that even though I don’t really have his problem with the Chronicle‘s practices (seemingly, the policy is to run supplied bylines unless they are somehow inaccurate), it might be nice to know the official policy.

I sent James T. Campbell a polite email inquiry about the policy, beginning with a discussion of the criticism (and an admission that I didn’t agree with the criticism). He responded fairly quickly that mine was a recurring question, and that he would visit with David Langworthy and get me an answer “tomorrow.”

I didn’t hear from Campbell the next day, so I emailed again and asked if he had been able to get a statement of policy from Langworthy.

No response.

A day later, I forwarded the correspondence to Langworthy, along with a repeat of the question.

Still no response, a week after the initial email.

I understand that editors probably have more important things to do than answer questions from bloggers, but it seems strange to promise an answer to a legitimate question about editorial policy and then not to deliver, and to ignore subsequent emails on the topic.

Given Langworthy’s “frank” column, it’s stranger still.


(Old) Forum Comments (2)

Kevin Whited
About Kevin Whited 4241 Articles
Kevin Whited is co-founder and publisher of blogHOUSTON. Follow him on twitter: @PubliusTX